As highlighted in my post on Tesla Model Y issues and the accessories that fix them, the Tesla Model Y floor mats are pretty bad. Although this is the norm for most new vehicles (many exclude floor mats altogether), at this price point I expect better. The carpeted offering is no match for any sort of weather. As such, floor mats should be your first accessory purchase. Thankfully, there are plenty of aftermarket options out there.
With that in mind, let’s break down the best Tesla Model Y floor mats and highlight our recommendation on which ones to buy.
Tesloid Model Y Floor Mats – 3D Extreme Performance
First up on this list of Tesla Model Y floor mats is Tesloid’s offering. These mats are designed to fit your Model Y perfectly and from my hands-on experience, they do just that. In fact, out of all the floor mats I tested, Tesloid has the best fit with no curling or gaps.
That said, the one drawback is that Tesloid’s Model Y floor mats do not go as high up the sides as some other options out there.
Still, these are a great option. They are durable and easy to clean. They’re also well priced at $149 CAD.
3D MAXpider All-Weather Floor Mats
Another very popular choice for Model Y floor mats is 3D MAXpider. These are often on sale at Costco and are one of the most talked-about options in Tesla forums and Facebook groups.
Out of all the floor mats I reviewed, the 3D MAXpider look the best. They have a premium look and feel whereas all other options are more function than style.
Now, of course, the look is subjective. For me, I would have liked to keep these ones for a summer set however I could not get over the logo. This looks tacky to me but, again, that is subjective.
What isn’t subjective is how they hold up to foot traffic. With minimal side coverage and a less than optimal fit, they will do little to stop mud and dirt getting into the side carpet areas. Some reviews online also highlight gaps in coverage on the end closest to the seats.
Tesmainian Model Y Floor Mats Interior Liners
Next up on this list of Model Y floor mats is the extremely popular Tesmanian all weather set. This set had the second-best fit next to Tesloid’s but is #1 overall when it comes to coverage. The sides on all Tesmanian mats extend the highest out of the mats I tested.
Still, the fit could be better. My set had a few spots that were curled, leaving large gaps. These are easy to address, however. All you need is a heat gun or hairdryer to mold the spots into shape.
YITAMOTOR Tesla Model Y Floor Mats
One of the best budget-friendly finds is the YITAMOTOR Tesla Model Y Floor Mats. At just $100 CAD, this set offers great value.
The fit is similar to Tesloid’s and coverage is good on all sides. The downfall is they do look like budget floor mats. And, if you are OCD like me, the logo might bug you.
Tesla Model Y OEM All-Weather Interior Liners
Those looking for OEM option are in luck. Tesla offers a set of all-weather floor mats in their store. Full disclosure, I did not try these ones. Why? The price.
At $225 CAD, these mats come in as the most expensive. After looking at them I decided to order the Tesmanian ones to try instead. They are pretty identical in looks, minus the Tesla lettering. Considering that, if everything Tesla is important to you (and the price is not a concern), these look like a solid choice.
BASENOR Tesla Model Y Floor Mat 3D All-Weather
Last up on this list of Tesla Model Y floor mats are the BASENOR 3D All-Weather set. These floor mats fit great and have an excellent no-slip design.
On the downside, they are very basic looking and have no coverage up the sides. The driver side is also a little short, leaving gaps for mud or dirt to get in.
So, Which Model Y Floor Mats Are for You?
After extensive testing, for me, it came down to Tesloid’s excellent fit and Tesmainian’s overall coverage. The 3D Maxider was a close 3rd however the logo and lack of side coverage sealed it for me.
Since it was a toss-up for me with the looks between Tesmainian and Tesloid, I took to Instagram and let the Interwebs decide which one I should keep. Drum roll, please…
What do you think? Which Tesla Model Y floor mats do you like? Is there a set out these that I should test and add to this list? Let me know in the comments below!